Fluffernutter Pie Recipe

entertaining recipe Jun 28, 2023
Fluffernutter Pie Recipe
  • 1 small container mallow fluff
  • 1 tub cool whip
  • 1 pint ice cream 
  • A few handfuls Spanish peanuts
  • 1/2 C. - 1 C. honey roasted peanut butter
  • 2 sleeves club crackers


  1. Line 8”x8” glass baking dish with criss-crossed parchment paper

  2. Cover bottom and sides of the dish with club crackers

  3. Mix ice cream and peanut butter together and smooth into the bottom of the dish on top of the crackers

  4. Cover ice cream layer with red peanuts

  5. Mix fluff and cool whip together and smooth over the peanut layer

  6. Cover top with club crackers; press that cracker layer evenly into the top

  7. Freeze at coldest temp you can for at least 8 hours and slice



  • If you want ice cream sandwich style bars, you need to freeze this as cold as you possibly can. Otherwise it is likely you’ll want to serve on a plate (which you will want to lick clean.)
  • Any peanut butter works, but if you’re buying some especially for this recipe, get a honey roast. Even better is the grind-your-own honey roasted peanut butter at Whole Foods. This delectably gritty texture and sweet-saltiness make the pie stand out. 
  • Have fun with your ice cream choice. Vanilla is obvious, but we used an ice cream with cookie pieces in it and that really added some depth. You could also do a nice toffee, sweet cream, or my personal favorite (which I will likely adapt for this blog) STRAWBERRY. 
  • This is an adaptation of a recipe I saw from Dan Pelosi ❤️ 

Would you like an opportunity to access a life coach with fifteen years’ experience, twice a month, for practically nothing? Check out Community Support, my app-accessible, self-priced coaching community!

Lemme See 👀

Would you like Cool Blog Stuff in your inbox at random?

Join my mailing list to receive emails. They’re really varied—recipes, stories, lists, news, etc.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.

I hate SPAM. I will never sell your information, for any reason. Not even if Pearl Jam asks me to.